Thursday, August 9, 2012

It's The Economy Stupid: Trade Balance & Jobless Claims

Economic Event

Period

Economic Survey

Actual Reported

Original Prior

Revised Prior

Trade Balance

JUN

-$47.5B

-$42.9B

-$48.7B

-$48.0B

Initial Jobless Claims

AUG 4

370K

361K

 365K

367K

Continuing Jobless Claims

JUL 28

3275K

3332K

3272K

3279K

 

Okay, better Initial Jobless Claims numbers.  Not great, but the jobless numbers seem to be no longer growing.  Jobless claims unexpectedly dropped by 6,000 to 361,000 in the week ended Aug. 4. The median forecast of 43 economists surveyed by Bloomberg News called for an increase to 370,000. Fewer firings mean employers are seeing enough demand to retain staff, indicating our economy may be sustaining the recovery from the recession.  Labor Department data last week showed payrolls rose more than forecast in July.  This is a good trend.

 

The Trade Balance numbers were much better.  Less imports, more exports.  Now that’s a trend we need to continue.  We need to improve OUR economy.  We cannot depend on European or Asian economic improvement. We need economic improvement.  The U.S. trade deficit narrowed more than forecast in June as the biggest drop in crude oil prices in more than three years helped cut the nation’s import bill.      The gap shrank 11 percent to $42.9 billion, the smallest

since December 2010, from $48 billion in May.

 

John Broussard

Assistant State Treasurer

Chief Investment Officer

State of Louisiana

Department of the Treasury

Ph:  225-342-0013

Fx:  225-342-9721

Email:  jbroussard@treasusry.state.la.us

Street Address:

445 North Blvd, 7th Floor

Baton Rouge, LA 70802

Mailing Address:

P.O. Box 44154 Capitol Station

Baton Rouge, LA 70804-4154

Physical Location:

One City Plaza, 7th Floor

Corner of North Blvd & 4th Street

Exit 1B I-110 Convention Street,

Turn Left to get to North Blvd,

Turn Right on North Blvd

 

Monday, August 6, 2012

WSJ: The Real 'Stimulus' Record

The Wall Street Journal.

Monday, August 06, 2012

 

Opinion

 

The Real ‘Stimulus’ Record

By Arthur B. Laffer

 

Policy makers in Washington and other capitals around the world are debating whether to implement another round of stimulus spending to combat high unemployment and sputtering growth rates. But before they leap, they should take a good hard look at how that worked the first time around.

 

It worked miserably, as indicated by the table nearby, which shows increases in government spending from 2007 to 2009 and subsequent changes in GDP growth rates. Of the 34 Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development nations, those with the largest spending spurts from 2007 to 2009 saw the least growth in GDP rates before and after the stimulus.

 

The four nations—Estonia, Ireland, the Slovak Republic and Finland—with the biggest stimulus programs had the steepest declines in growth. The United States was no different, with greater spending (up 7.3%) followed by far lower growth rates (down 8.4%).

 

 

Still, the debate rages between those who espouse stimulus spending as a remedy for our weak economy and those who argue it is the cause of our current malaise. The numbers at stake aren't small. Federal government spending as a share of GDP rose to a high of 27.3% in 2009 from 21.4% in late 2007. This increase is virtually all stimulus spending, including add-ons to the agricultural and housing bills in 2007, the $600 per capita tax rebate in 2008, the TARP and Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac bailouts, "cash for clunkers," additional mortgage relief subsidies and, of course, President Obama's $860 billion stimulus plan that promised to deliver unemployment rates below 6% by now. Stimulus spending over the past five years totaled more than $4 trillion.

 

If you believe, as I do, that the macro economy is the sum total of all of its micro parts, then stimulus spending really doesn't make much sense. In essence, it's when government takes additional resources beyond what it would otherwise take from one group of people (usually the people who produced the resources) and then gives those resources to another group of people (often to non-workers and non-producers).

 

Often as not, the qualification for receiving stimulus funds is the absence of work or income—such as banks and companies that fail, solar energy companies that can't make it on their own, unemployment benefits and the like. Quite simply, government taxing people more who work and then giving more money to people who don't work is a surefire recipe for less work, less output and more unemployment.

 

Yet the notion that additional spending is a "stimulus" and less spending is "austerity" is the norm just about everywhere. Without ever thinking where the money comes from, politicians and many economists believe additional government spending adds to aggregate demand. You'd think that single-entry accounting were the God's truth and that, for the government at least, every check written has no offsetting debit.

 

Well, the truth is that government spending does come with debits. For every additional government dollar spent there is an additional private dollar taken. All the stimulus to the spending recipients is matched on a dollar-for-dollar basis every minute of every day by a depressant placed on the people who pay for these transfers. Or as a student of the dismal science might say, the total income effects of additional government spending always sum to zero.

 

Meanwhile, what economists call the substitution or price effects of stimulus spending are negative for all parties. In other words, the transfer recipient has found a way to get paid without working, which makes not working more attractive, and the transfer payer gets paid less for working, again lowering incentives to work.

 

But all of this is just old-timey price theory, the stuff that used to be taught in graduate economics departments. Today, even stimulus spending advocates have their Ph.D. defenders. But there's no arguing with the data in the nearby table, and the fact that greater stimulus spending was followed by lower growth rates. Stimulus advocates have a lot of explaining to do. Their massive spending programs have hurt the economy and left us with huge bills to pay. Not a very nice combination.

 

Sorry, Keynesians. There was no discernible two or three dollar multiplier effect from every dollar the government spent and borrowed. In reality, every dollar of public-sector spending on stimulus simply wiped out a dollar of private investment and output, resulting in an overall decline in GDP. This is an even more astonishing result because government spending is counted in official GDP numbers. In other words, the spending was more like a valium for lethargic economies than a stimulant.

 

In many countries, an economic downturn, no matter how it's caused or the degree of change in the rate of growth, will trigger increases in public spending and therefore the appearance of a negative relationship between stimulus spending and economic growth. That is why the table focuses on changes in the rate of GDP growth, which helps isolate the effects of additional spending.

 

The evidence here is extremely damaging to the case made by Mr. Obama and others that there is economic value to spending more money on infrastructure, education, unemployment insurance, food stamps, windmills and bailouts. Mr. Obama keeps saying that if only Congress would pass his second stimulus plan, unemployment would finally start to fall. That's an expensive leap of faith with no evidence to confirm it.

 

------------------------

 

Mr. Laffer, chairman of Laffer Associates and the Laffer Center for Supply-Side Economics, is co-author, with Stephen Moore, of "Return to Prosperity: How America Can Regain Its Economic Superpower Status" (Threshold, 2010).

 

A version of this article appeared August 6, 2012, on page A13 in the U.S. edition of The Wall Street Journal, with the headline: The Real 'Stimulus' Record.

 

 

The Bernanke

Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke issued a statement this morning acknowledging that many people and businesses are facing tough times despite the fact that many of the broad measurements of the economy point to a slow recovery. "Even though some key aggregate metrics—including consumer spending, disposable income, household net worth, and debt service payments—have moved in the direction of recovery, it is clear that many individuals and households continue to struggle with difficult economic and financial conditions," he says in a prepared text.

 

Gee Ben, YA THINK!

 

 

John Broussard

Assistant State Treasurer

Chief Investment Officer

State of Louisiana

Department of the Treasury

 

Thursday, August 2, 2012

It's The Economy Stupid: Joblessness

Jobless claims are up from last week.  It’s not real bad in and of itself, just continued indication of a weak economy.  Supposedly the last couple of week’s numbers were weak due to the seasonal auto plant shutdowns.  Yeah, yeah, yeah, statistical noise.  The bottom line is job growth has been insufficient.

 

Economic Event

Period

Economic Survey

Actual Reported

Original Prior

Revised Prior

Challenger Job Cuts YoY

JUL

 

-44.5%

-9.4%

 

RBC Consumer Outlook Index

AUG

       46.4

          47.0

 

Initial Jobless Claims

JUL 28

370K

365K

353K

357K

Continuing Jobless Claims

JUL 21

3288K

3272K

3287K

3291K

 

The Challenger Job Cuts report today showed employers announced fewer job cuts in July than the same month last year as dismissals eased

at retailers, government agencies and some manufacturers.   Planned firings fell 44.5 percent from July 2011 to a 15-month low of 36,855, according to figures released by Chicago-based Challenger, Gray & Christmas Inc. The year-over-year decline in dismissals was the biggest since January 2011.

 

The four-week moving average for jobless claims, a less volatile measure than the weekly figures, fell to 365,500 last week, the lowest since March, from 368,250.

 

John Broussard

Assistant State Treasurer

Chief Investment Officer

State of Louisiana

Department of the Treasury

 

Wednesday, August 1, 2012

Bridgewater Daily Observations

A good succinct summary of the economy.

 

Bridgewater Daily Observations, August 1, 2012

 

As discussed previously, the US economy has slowed to a moderate growth rate in recent months, dragged down by weak household demand.  Household spending remains highly dependent on income growth, as the ability to borrow and spend remains much more constrained than in normal cyclical expansions.  Over shorter periods, when there has been significant stimulation, household spending has been somewhat stronger than incomes (i.e., savings rates declined).  But as the effects of stimulation have faded in recent months, household spending growth has been even weaker than income growth, savings rates have risen, and household spending has been one of the weaker spots of the US economy.  Conditions facing households have improved recently, as equity prices have recovered somewhat in recent weeks, home prices may have bottomed out, and interest rates have reached new lows.  Some of these modest improvements appear to be reflected in the July consumer confidence surveys, which improved slightly from June.  Over time, we would expect household spending growth rates to approximate the pace of income growth.  While this would be an improvement, without further stimulation household spending is likely to remain mediocre.

 

ECONOMICS FOR DUMMIES:

 

Consumer spending is a substantial part of the economy.  It’s hard for the economy to do well if the consumer is not spending money.

 

“…household spending growth has been even weaker than income growth, savings rates have risen, and household spending has been one of the weaker spots of the US economy.” – The consumer is reducing debt, paying cash as they go, saving more, investing less, and not increasing their spending on goods and services as they worry about the economy and their jobs.     

 

“Over time, we would expect household spending growth rates to approximate the pace of income growth.” -  Income growth has been week, consumer spending has been weak, therefore incomes would have to increase in order for consumer spending to increase and in order for the economy to thrive.

 

“While this would be an improvement, without further stimulation household spending is likely to remain mediocre.” - No one is forecasting income increases, so the economy is not likely to be all that great.

 

 

 

John Broussard

Assistant State Treasurer

Chief Investment Officer

State of Louisiana

Department of the Treasury

 

It's The Economy Stupid: ADP Jobs

ADP Employment Change  JULY  +163K, economist estimated 120K.  This is down slightly from the prior periods +172K.

 

Modest growth in job creation is a good thing, and the ADP number suggests a modest decline in the unemployment rate.  But the economy needs to put 5 million to 7 million people back to work, so what we really need is change in the +300K range.  So it’s positive, but it continues to show a very sluggish recovery.

 

The ADP number has been the best of a bad set of economic numbers.

 

 

John Broussard

Assistant State Treasurer

Chief Investment Officer

State of Louisiana

Department of the Treasury

 

Tuesday, July 31, 2012

Bill Gross: The Cult of Equity Is Dying

Okay, this commentary by Bill Gross is scary.  If he's right, public pension plans with assumed rates of return of 7%, 7.5%, 8% are in for a world of hurt.  But then so is the entire investor class.

 

http://www.pimco.com/EN/Insights/Pages/Cult-Figures.aspx

 

Excerpts from the Bill Gross of PIMCO Investment Commentary:

 

Cult Figures

•​The long-term history of inflation adjusted returns from stocks shows a persistent but recently fading 6.6% real return since 1912 - The Siegel constant of 6.6% real appreciation. 

•The legitimate question that market analysts, government forecasters and pension consultants should answer is how that return can be duplicated in the future.

•Unfair though it may be, an investor should continue to expect an attempted inflationary solution in almost all developed economies over the next few years and even decades.

 

"The cult of equity is dying."

 

"With long Treasuries currently yielding 2.55%, it is even more of a stretch to assume that long-term bonds – and the bond market – will replicate the performance of decades past."

 

"The Siegel constant of 6.6% real appreciation, therefore, is an historical freak, a mutation likely never to be seen again as far as we mortals are concerned."

 

 

John Broussard

Assistant State Treasurer

Chief Investment Officer

State of Louisiana

Department of the Treasury